|
The first iteration of the deadly fight between the big diesel hatches on a mission to gun down gasoline saw the Swift DDiS emerge as the most lethal oil burner. The small gasoline hatches , in the meantime , are engaged in an intra-racial skirmish for survival. There�s a new , extremely potent killer on the block. This hostile Hyundai hailing from South Korea is called the i20 and it is ready to challenge the might of champions from Germany and Japan. It�s going to be One hell of a fight.
To understand the magnitude of the i20 as a new contender , we need to rewind about five years back in time. Those of you who have a profound interest in cars would recollect that Korean cars were considered in a league of their own when it came to aesthetics. They were crowned the ugliest cars on the face of this planet almost unanimously. Like that was not a big enough accolade , these cars featured poor technology , were flimsily put together and drove like metallic incarnations of disappointment itself. That was also the time when Hyundai was emerging on the global automotive scene as a powerful player , and even though the company didn�t have an authentically well-engineered car to its credit , most small and midsize Hyundais were known to do their job reasonably well. Yet for most international auto journalists , bringing out the topic of Korean cars still meant that it was time to crack jokes. And it wasn�t very different in India either , where there weren�t too many quality offerings to begin with. Hyundai�s small cars went down well with the market because of their low cost and economical running , but nobody was confident about the more expensive offerings of the company � a segment where technology and sophistication take prominence over economy. Somehow Hyundai cars didn�t quite match the high European standards of quality , technology and design.
Circa 2007 � the Hyundai i10 specifically designed and developed for Europe changed the way people looked at the Korean marque. The i10�s clean sweep of the Indian Car of the Year awards was unprecedented. Be it any department � design , comfort , space or refinement; the i10 bettered its competition in the country on every count and by a good margin. The i10 was a contemporary , quality product , ready to take the fight to the biggies. The fact reflected on the growth of the company. Local sales and exports soared , and the Korean giant posted exceptionally healthy figures throughout 2008 when all the other auto players were feeling the heat of the recession. Hyundai had proven its authority in the small car market. This , however , was not the segment where we doubted the Korean company�s capabilities anyway. The i20 is a very important car because it�s the next link in the progression. Presenting products as immaculate as the i10 in higher segments (the i30 in Europe) will prove Hyundai�s aptitude as a complete carmaker and the i20 is the next logical step in that direction. What makes this comparo interesting is the fact that we have the Skoda Fabia � a car that was designed for the demanding European market and has met with great success there. The Swift , the other contender in this shootout , is the car that was the biggest deterrent in the success of the Getz. Evaluating the i20 against its cousin�s nemesis will be interesting.
To start with , the new Hyundai shatters the earlier perception about the design of Korean cars to pieces. The i20 exhibits exceptional flair and flamboyance. It doesn�t need any discussion or argument to emerge as the best looking car of the trio , one look would be enough. The sleek and slim twin grille at the front flanks the Hyundai emblem. Twin creases on the bonnet converge under the Hyundai insignia to form a U. The vertically tapering headlamps end into a ridge that runs all through the flanks of the bonnet and merge seamlessly into the A pillars of the car. The big central air-dam with slightly popped out headlamps completes the front which manages to blend aggression , funkiness and elegance in just the right proportions. Somehow , standing behind the ORVMS and looking at the swollen headlamps reminds me of the A-star. The windscreen is sharply raked and further accentuates the i20�s sportiness at the front. The slant reaches its peak soon after the windscreen ends and dips back sharply again to lend the car that racy roofline � a popular trend these days. An extremely strong crease starting from above the front fender and ending in a curve parallel to the rear wheel arch along with an equally pronounced dip in the lower part of the doors give the i20 a distinctive profile.
The tail lamps of the i20 somehow remind me of the S-class. The latter too has a band of two parallel red glass strips separated by a white glass band. The huge tail lamps extrude the rear end and enter the side area of the car between the C pillar and above the rear fender. Full points to Hyundai designers who have managed to pull out a perfect blend of cheekiness , sporty stance and elegance. The i20 is by far the best looking B segmenter out there. In comparison , the Fabia is more of a conformist and looks somewhat feminine , even , from certain angles. The Swift�s oddball form was almost revolutionary at the time of its launch but it�s beginning to get boring now.
Inside the new Hyundai�s cabin , a clean , uncluttered and pleasing layout welcomes you. The central console is a big departure from the minimalist central units in this category of cars. Big buttons for easy access , well sorted controls , use of good quality plastics and a distinctive design � the i20�s dash reminds you of some much more expensive cars. Above the central console , that has a seatbelt warning for all the five seats as standard , you have a digital readout for trip , odo and other info. We thought that the i20�s readout will display data like distance to dry , instantaneous fuel efficiency , etc. like the Fabia , but to our disappointment , that was not the case. Aspi wasn�t too fond of the chocolate brown-beige interiors. He was very critical of the colour choice especially as Hyundai could have chosen a classier colour without any extra cost overheads. i found the brown colour nice enough though. The Civic and CR-V style three-spoke steering wheel with aluminium inserts spells jazz. With steering mounted audio controls , the car looks too good to be true for its segment. A closer inspection and a few taps on the aluminium finish panel reveal that some cost cutting has gone into that beautiful look. The aluminium bit may feel slightly cheap but it looks smashing. The leather wrapped wheel , however , feels as nice as it looks. The clean dash of the i20 augments the feeling of space. The instrumentation layout is conformist in a good way � black dial , big , white and clear font. The speedo and odo flank the temperature and fuel gauge. Panels in the cabin meet seamlessly , the finish of the interior is splendid and the immaculate execution witnessed in the i10 seems to have been further improved. The quality of material used for the brown dash isn�t exactly bad or disappointing , but it still feels harder to touch than it ideally should. The way it looks , one would expect it to feel softer and suppler. Even the lower beige panels feel slightly scratchy and brittle. Overall , the quality inside the cabin is commendable and good enough to give the Fabia , the hitherto class leader in that department the heebie-jeebies.
The Swift is showing its age on the interiors front and the amenities that you get as standard even in the i20 Magna trim (bottom of the line) overshadow the Swift�s higher spec variants� list by a humongous margin. Automatic climate control , tilt and telescopic steering wheel , rear aircon vents , height adjustable driver�s seat , seatbelt warning for all passengers , the list of features in the i20 keeps going on and on. The Swift is totally outclassed here. The Fabia , offering a contemporary , high quality , European standard interior seems comparable with the i20�s cabin. However , the i20 pips the Skoda by offering a much superior stereo system with options for auxiliary and USB input , (much) better sound quality with four speakers against the Fabia�s two-speaker audio system which is a disappointment. Also , the Fabia doesn�t have steering mounted volume controls � a letdown for the price at which it�s being sold here. Visually too , the i20�s cabin looks more lively and jazzier than the Fabia�s understated interior. The only functionality that the Fabia has and the i20 doesn�t , is the trip computer that gives you data like instantaneous efficiency , average efficiency , distance to dry and heaps of other info � very useful. The i20 is less spacious than the Fabia , but only marginally so. The Swift doesn�t stand a chance against the two options here when it comes to backseat space and comfort. Add to the i20�s arsenal , an option of as many a six airbags for safety and the Hyundai emerges as the clear winner among the three cars as far as interiors go.
The i20 rides on an all-new platform aimed to deliver the lively driving dynamics demanded by the European market. The car was extensively tested on European roads. Hot weather testing was carried out in Spain , cold weather trials took place in Sweden while high speed testing was completed in Germany. As a result , the i20�s front MacPherson strut and rear torsion beam suspension manage to deliver a good blend of dynamic stability and ride comfort. The car behaves well around corners , feels poised and begs to be driven hard. The small 1.2-litre Kappa engine though doesn�t really have the sort of power to let us test the dynamic ability of this car to the limit. With a 185 section rubber , some may call the i20 an over-tyred car but it aids grip around bends tremendously. The i20 can probably do with thinner rubber for better efficiency but then you should be ready for the Swift-like squeals the skinny tyres would make at every attempt to guide the car around bends even at mediocre speeds.
The i20�s new rack and pinion steering setup has also been tuned to deliver quick and accurate responses for easy City manoeuvring , and great feedback around corners. Extensive use of advanced noise reduction materials , as Hyundai claim , has resulted in a quiet cabin. In comparison , the Fabia , with its European focus is a terrifically poised car around corners. It takes a lot to unsettle this Skoda from the chosen line. The wide tyres won�t let the Fabia wag its tail unless you really want to test your luck. The steering feels heavy and transmits a solid feel to your palms. It isn�t as fluid and effortless as the i20 at low speeds but doesn�t feel inconvenient either. The ride quality of the Fabia , however , is slightly on the harsher side. Passing over undulations at low speeds makes you experience a slight bounce while at higher speeds you can hear a distinct thud. While the stiffer setting helps the dynamics at high speeds , comfort takes a slight hit. The i20 is suppler and more cushioned.
On to the most important aspects then � engine and gearbox. Why so late? Well , none of the engines on the three cars are convincing enough. We have experienced the 1.2-litre Kappa unit on the i10 earlier and really appreciated its smoothness and refinement. However , for a car that weighs more than a tonne and has a 185 section rubber providing grip , the i20�s 80PS gasoline engine feels somewhat disappointing. As one would imagine , the car doesn�t feel too peppy or sprightly for its size. But there still is a sense of tractability and responsiveness about that Kappa unit. You put the right foot down and the engine will not feel overloaded or non-responsive. Of course , there is a lack of power reflected in the in-gear acceleration figures but the more important thing here is that while the car doesn�t push you back with a shove , it doesn�t feel entirely breathless too at lower revs.
More photos:
|
To understand the magnitude of the i20 as a new contender , we need to rewind about five years back in time. Those of you who have a profound interest in cars would recollect that Korean cars were considered in a league of their own when it came to aesthetics. They were crowned the ugliest cars on the face of this planet almost unanimously. Like that was not a big enough accolade , these cars featured poor technology , were flimsily put together and drove like metallic incarnations of disappointment itself. That was also the time when Hyundai was emerging on the global automotive scene as a powerful player , and even though the company didn�t have an authentically well-engineered car to its credit , most small and midsize Hyundais were known to do their job reasonably well. Yet for most international auto journalists , bringing out the topic of Korean cars still meant that it was time to crack jokes. And it wasn�t very different in India either , where there weren�t too many quality offerings to begin with. Hyundai�s small cars went down well with the market because of their low cost and economical running , but nobody was confident about the more expensive offerings of the company � a segment where technology and sophistication take prominence over economy. Somehow Hyundai cars didn�t quite match the high European standards of quality , technology and design.
Circa 2007 � the Hyundai i10 specifically designed and developed for Europe changed the way people looked at the Korean marque. The i10�s clean sweep of the Indian Car of the Year awards was unprecedented. Be it any department � design , comfort , space or refinement; the i10 bettered its competition in the country on every count and by a good margin. The i10 was a contemporary , quality product , ready to take the fight to the biggies. The fact reflected on the growth of the company. Local sales and exports soared , and the Korean giant posted exceptionally healthy figures throughout 2008 when all the other auto players were feeling the heat of the recession. Hyundai had
proven its authority in the small car market. This , however , was not the segment where we doubted the Korean company�s capabilities anyway. The i20 is a very important car because it�s the next link in the progression. Presenting products as immaculate as the i10 in higher segments (the i30 in Europe) will prove Hyundai�s aptitude as a complete carmaker and the i20 is the next logical step in that direction. What makes this comparo interesting is the fact that we have the Skoda Fabia � a car that was designed for the demanding European market and has met with great success there. The Swift , the other contender in this shootout , is the car that was the biggest deterrent in the success of the Getz. Evaluating the i20 against its cousin�s nemesis will be interesting.
To start with , the new Hyundai shatters the earlier perception about the design of Korean cars to pieces. The i20 exhibits exceptional flair and flamboyance. It doesn�t need any discussion or argument to emerge as the best looking car of the trio , one look would be enough. The sleek and slim twin grille at the front flanks the Hyundai emblem. Twin creases on the bonnet converge under the Hyundai insignia to form a U. The vertically tapering headlamps end into a ridge that runs all through the flanks of the bonnet and merge seamlessly into the A pillars of the car. The big central air-dam with slightly popped out headlamps completes the front which manages to blend aggression , funkiness and elegance in just the right proportions. Somehow , standing behind the ORVMS and looking at the swollen headlamps reminds me of the A-star. The windscreen is sharply raked and further accentuates the i20�s sportiness at the front. The slant reaches its peak soon after the windscreen ends and dips back sharply again to lend the car that racy roofline � a popular trend these days. An extremely strong crease starting from above the front fender and ending in a curve parallel to the rear wheel arch along with an equally pronounced dip in the lower part of the doors give the i20 a distinctive profile.
The tail lamps of the i20 somehow remind me of the S-class. The latter too has a band of two parallel red glass strips separated by a white glass band. The huge tail lamps extrude the rear end and enter the side area of the car between the C pillar and above the rear fender. Full points to Hyundai designers who have managed to pull out a perfect blend of cheekiness , sporty stance and elegance. The i20 is by far the best looking B segmenter out there. In comparison , the Fabia is more of a conformist and looks somewhat feminine , even , from certain angles. The Swift�s oddball form was almost revolutionary at the time of its launch but it�s beginning to get boring now.
The Swift is showing its age on the interiors front and the amenities that you get as standard even in the i20 Magna trim (bottom of the line) overshadow the Swift�s higher spec variants� list by a humongous margin. Automatic climate control , tilt and telescopic steering wheel , rear aircon vents , height adjustable driver�s seat , seatbelt warning for all passengers , the list of features in the i20 keeps going on and on. The Swift is totally outclassed here. The Fabia , offering a contemporary , high quality , European standard interior seems comparable with the i20�s cabin. However , the i20 pips the Skoda by offering a much superior stereo system with options for auxiliary and USB input , (much) better sound quality with four speakers against the Fabia�s two-speaker audio system which is a disappointment. Also , the Fabia doesn�t have steering mounted volume controls � a letdown for the price at which it�s being sold here. Visually too , the i20�s cabin looks more lively and jazzier than the Fabia�s understated interior. The only functionality that the
Fabia has and the i20 doesn�t , is the trip computer that gives you data like instantaneous efficiency , average efficiency , distance to dry and heaps of other info � very useful. The i20 is less spacious than the Fabia , but only marginally so. The Swift doesn�t stand a chance against the two options here when it comes to backseat space and comfort. Add to the i20�s arsenal , an option of as many a six airbags for safety and the Hyundai emerges as the clear winner among the three cars as far as interiors go.
The i20 rides on an all-new platform aimed to deliver the lively driving dynamics demanded by the European market. The car was extensively tested on European roads. Hot weather testing was carried out in Spain , cold weather trials took place in Sweden while high speed testing was completed in Germany. As a result , the i20�s front MacPherson strut and rear torsion beam suspension manage to deliver a good blend of dynamic stability and ride comfort. The car behaves well around corners , feels poised and begs to be driven hard. The small 1.2-litre Kappa engine though doesn�t really have the sort of power to let us test the dynamic ability of this car to the limit. With a 185 section rubber , some may call the i20 an over-tyred car but it aids grip around bends tremendously. The i20 can probably do with thinner rubber for better efficiency but then you should be ready for the Swift-like squeals the skinny tyres would make at every attempt to guide the car around bends even at mediocre speeds.
The i20�s new rack and pinion steering setup has also been tuned to deliver quick and accurate responses for easy City manoeuvring , and great feedback around corners. Extensive use of advanced noise reduction materials , as Hyundai claim , has resulted in a quiet cabin. In comparison , the Fabia , with its European focus is a terrifically poised car around corners. It takes a lot to unsettle this Skoda from the chosen line. The wide tyres won�t let the Fabia wag its tail unless you really want to test your luck. The steering feels heavy and transmits a solid feel to your palms. It isn�t as fluid and effortless as the i20 at low speeds but doesn�t feel inconvenient either. The ride quality of the Fabia , however , is slightly on the harsher side. Passing over undulations at low speeds makes you experience a slight bounce while at higher speeds you can hear a distinct thud. While the stiffer setting helps the dynamics at high speeds , comfort takes a slight hit. The i20 is suppler and more cushioned.
On to the most important aspects then � engine and gearbox. Why so late? Well , none of the engines on the three cars are convincing enough. We have experienced the 1.2-litre Kappa unit on the i10 earlier and really appreciated its smoothness and refinement. However , for a car that weighs more than a tonne and has a 185 section rubber providing grip , the i20�s 80PS gasoline engine feels somewhat disappointing. As one would imagine , the car doesn�t feel too peppy or sprightly for its size. But there still is a sense of tractability and responsiveness about that Kappa unit. You put the right foot down and the engine will not feel overloaded or non-responsive. Of course , there is a lack of power reflected in the in-gear acceleration figures but the more important thing here is that while the car doesn�t push you back with a shove , it doesn�t feel entirely breathless too at lower revs.
More photos:
Content courtesy:
sir,i want to buy a diesal car in between 5 to 7 lakh,my first choice is i20sportz,,but a little confused to spend 7 lakh on a hathback,many sedans comes at this price like dzire,please give me solution
sir should i go for i20 magna or shift?
i 20 best in hatches
dear sir i was planning to buy i20 or i30..so which will have better comfort and milage too from the above given option. And also please may i know the actul price for this two cars.
Sir m bit confused to between i-20 and swift!! wich one will b better to buy...?
Swift is the best ,of the lot an DDSI she rules...
Why is the Indica Vista not part of this comparo. It would have been good to see that car battling out with the Chaebol, Japs and Czech.
I still feel that the Korean cars lack the feel or sense of a character when compared to the Japanese or European cars. They (hyundai) have improved with quality though.
I am planning to buy a car which is cost effective, fuel efficient rich features, lesser maintenance cost and good re-sale value within a range of Rs. 8 lacs be it a petrol and diesel. I am planning to buy on SOS basis but little confused which one should buy?
Mr Devenra: I totally respect Mr Pradeep's point of view. I would however suggest you to even consider the all new Fiat Linea Petrol / Diesel. Fiat develops some of the best diesel engines. They have also bagged awards for best diesel engine in Europe. The same engine is being use by the Maruti Suzuki with some slight modifications in their Swift and Swift Dzire models. I somehow found the Swift Dzire a bit awkward and wierd in terms of design. Linea though is simply admirable and Dzireable.
Devenra, You should go for Diesl Swift Dzire.
I am planning to buy automatic version of i10.Can u send review on i10A/T
I am planning to buy an Car in the range of 6-8Lacs and up to know i have shortlisted three one Maruti swift Dzire, Hyundai Verna and Fiat Linea Emotional but i am bit confused which one should i but which can be cost efffective , low maintenance and good milage. Please let me know your views on the same.
if looking btween 6-8 lakhs go for honda city or sx4
its cooooooooooooooooooooooool
I am planning to buy a diesel car between 6-7 lakhs and have shortlisted two cars ie maruthi swift VDI ABS and i20 magna diesel. Can any help in deciding.
Why cant you try Honda Jazz , a beauty for maoney
thorough comparison.. but how about the other hatchback rivals of i20 apart from swift & fabia. How about ford fusion & Chevrolet aveo. My heart was sold to City but it is now 10+.. so looking at hatchback options now
I am planning to buy a car which is cost effective, fuel efficient rich features, lesser maintenance cost and good re-sale value within a range of Rs. 8 lacs diesel. I am planning to buy on SOS basis but little confused which one should buy
i want to buy a new dieasl car in next mounth but am coffused in i20 magna and swieft pls sugest me.
sir i want buy the swift car. monthly once or twoes i traval 600 km. which one best diesel or petrol kindly suggesess to me
i am planning to buy hatch back disel car range between 6 and 8lacs. bit confused between hyundai i20sportz disel and swift vdi pls do suggest me which is best